Designing a benchmarking tool
This post explains the development of a semi-automated benchmark tool to review how embedded sustainability is into university research and the undergraduate curriculum. It also maps it to the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals or SDG’s, a collection of 17 goals to make the world more sustainable. Undertaken by students from Worcester Polytechnic Institute (WPI) in Massachusetts USA. Applied initially at the University of Worcester but its overall aims are to make something available freely to the higher education sector. The tool is made up of 2 sets of questions, about the curriculum and research. It also uses software for analyzing modules and research articles based on a set of sustainability-related keywords.
We have been working on improving the set of keywords used by the software. We removed the keywords that were too general and added many keywords and phrases to reflect the Sustainable Development Goals. We also updated some of the questions to have more clarity and obtain more insightful information.
Results for University of Worcester
Once we updated the tool, we applied it to the University of Worcester. We found that they score really well for sustainability in both their curriculum and research, see figures below. The red line maximum score has been taken from the AASHE STARS benchmarking tool used predominately in American universities to benchmark their sustainability. As this is a proven and well-used tool this ‘best practice’ reference point has been used on the first iteration of this tool. We acknowledge that this will need to change both as the usage of the tool is more widespread and also as universities more fully embedded sustainability into their teaching and research.
Mapping to the SDG’s
The best new feature of the module and research analyzing software is the ability to map the modules or research articles to the Sustainable Development Goals. The University of Worcester has a focus on SDG3, Health and Wellbeing, and SDG1, No Poverty, in every aspect of what they teach.
SDGs in Sustainability-Related Modules
SDGs in Sustainability-Related Research Articles
Once we finished updating and applying the benchmarking tool at the University of Worcester, we wanted to create a way for more universities to use our tool. We decided that creating a website would be the best way of easily sharing the tool. The website could run the research and module analyzing software and have a place to answer all the questions.
The hardest part of sharing the benchmarking tool with other universities is modifying the software to work on the research and modules of any university.
We also worked with Kingston University to improve the sustainability benchmarking tool. When we tried to apply the tool at Kingston University, we ran into a few major challenges. These challenges gave us insight into the difficulty of developing a universal benchmarking tool. We found that universities don’t store their module directories or research publications in a constant format. That makes our software very difficult to use. Also, the staff members that answer our questions for some parts of the benchmarking tool aren’t in the same positions which makes our benchmarking tool more time-consuming.
The benchmarking tool works really well on the University of Worcester. We would love to one day see this tool work at all universities across the UK. It’s going to take more interaction with other universities to develop a common way of storing data. Once this problem is solved the possibilities are endless.
Watch a 10-minute video presentation about this project
Benchmark your university
We welcome universities who wish to run the tool with their data so do please use the comments box below to get in touch.